If possible, use a small cookie scoop to measure out the dough. Level off the top of the cookie scoop before placing a piece of dough onto the lined baking sheet. Add 12 pieces of cookie dough onto a baking sheet, leaving about 1.5 to 2 inches of space between each ball of dough.
If you don’t have a small cookie scoop, spray a teaspoon measuring spoon with cooking spray and measure 2 teaspoons of dough for each cookie. You’ll need to roll up the dough into a ball with greased hands. If that’s too time consuming, you can make slightly larger cookies with a tablespoon measure. If the dough starts sticking to the spoon, apply more cooking spray to the measuring spoon.
Use cooking spray to grease both sides of a mini silicone spatula or the bottom of a drinking glass or measuring cup. Using a silicone spatula gives you the most control over shaping the cookies, but using a drinking glass or measuring cup is faster.
If you’re using a silicone spatula, start by gently pressing the spatula down on a piece of cookie dough. Then, lift the spatula and press down on another part of the cookie to flatten it. Keep pressing and lifting the spatula until you get a flat disc of about 2 inches in diameter. Resist the urge to drag the spatula over the cookie dough to try to shape it into a circle. The dough will stick to the spatula more quickly this way.
Alternatively, press the bottom of the greased glass or measuring cup over a piece of dough to flatten it into a circle of about 2 inches in diameter. The circle might not be perfectly round, so use a greased spatula or butter knife to shift the edges into a neat circle.
When the dough is starting to stick to the spatula, glass, or measuring cup, reapply cooking spray. I like to spray a small bowl with cooking spray so that I can easily reapply cooking spray with my fingers.
Once you’ve flattened all 12 cookies, they are ready to bake. Place the remaining cookie dough back into the fridge.