Now that tomatoes are in season, I want to cook with them all the time. They have robust flavor and add a lovely hue to your dishes. One of my favorite things to cook with tomatoes is chicken tikka masala. “Tikka” in Indian cuisine refers to pieces of meat or vegetables marinated in spices. “Masala” refers to blends of spices in paste or powder form. Chicken tikka masala, then, is a dish of cooked marinated chicken pieces that’s bathed in a rich tomato sauce.
In this recipe, I make a vegetarian version using paneer instead of chicken. Although I use a number of spices in this paneer tikka masala recipe, it is simple to cook. The paneer has a lovely flavorful crust on the outside, and it pair so well with the masala sauce.
HOW TO MAKE PANEER TIKKA MASALA
MARINATE PANEER IN SPICED YOGURT
The preparation for this paneer tikka masala is similar to chicken tikka masala in that you marinate the paneer in yogurt and spices. The yogurt helps coat the paneer pieces with spices. When you pan fry the paneer, the yogurt forms a thin crust around the exterior.
The paneer that you see in the photos are store bought. The brand is called Gopi, and I usually buy it from Nugget Markets or the Sacramento Co-Op. Although I make paneer often, it crumbles a lot easier than packaged paneer. Because this recipe requires marinating, pan-frying and simmering the paneer, I opted for paneer that’s a little sturdier. Feel free to use fresh paneer if you want!
PAN FRY THE PANEER
You can do this step before or while you make the sauce. I usually pan fry the paneer first because they can burn easily (as you’ll see below).
A 14-ounce block of paneer will yield a lot of pieces, cook the paneer in two batches. After cooking the first batch, wipe down the pan with a paper towel to get rid any burned black bits.
By the time you get to the second batch, the pan will already be very hot. The marinated paneer splatters a lot when you place them on the pan, so be careful. Also, the second batch tends to cook a little quicker.
When I was preparing the paneer for these photos, I absent-mindedly scrolled through my phone while waiting for the paneer to fry. Before realizing it, I scorched the paneer (see photo above, right). You actually want the paneer to look like the ones in the left photo. I still ate all of it, but don’t make the same mistake I did!
By the way, you’ll inevitably have some yogurt marinade left over. Don’t throw it away! I usually add it to the sauce towards the end.
MAKE THE SAUCE
This step involves sautéing the onions and spices and simmering the tomatoes with liquid. In the photos, I used fresh tomatoes from the farmers market, but canned tomatoes work as well. Note that canned tomatoes tend to be more acidic, so you may need to add a little more sugar to the sauce to balance out the acidity.
Once you have cooked and simmered the ingredients for the sauce, you can leave the sauce as is or blend it in a high-speed blender. If you blend the sauce, the dish will look more like something you’d get at a restaurant. However, I’m also lazy sometimes and cannot be bothered to transfer everything to a blender. Choose whichever option you prefer. For reference, the first photo of this post features the sauce unblended; the photo above shows the blended sauce.
After you are done cooking the sauce, add the paneer back to the pan. Heat the paneer for 1 or 2 minutes and serve.
IS HEAVY CREAM NECESSARY FOR THE SAUCE?
Heavy cream helps balance the acidity of the tomatoes and gives the sauce a lovely creaminess. Many recipes call for a lot of heavy cream, and I have tried to keep the calories down by using only 3 tablespoons. If you are truly averse to heavy cream, use 3 or 4 tablespoons of whole milk yogurt.
MORE PANEER RECIPES
Paneer Tikka Masala
Ingredients
Paneer
- 14 ounces paneer (see note 1)
- 6 tablespoons plain whole milk yogurt (see note 2)
- 1 teaspoon grated ginger
- 2 cloves of garlic, grated
- 1 teaspoon cumin
- 1 teaspoon paprika
- 3/4 teaspoon kosher salt
- 3 tablespoons safflower or canola oil
Masala Sauce
- 2 tablespoons safflower or canola oil
- 1 medium onion, thinly sliced (about 1 cup sliced)
- 1 1/2 teaspoons kosher salt, divided
- 2 teaspoons grated ginger
- 4 cloves garlic, minced
- 1 tablespoon ground coriander
- 2 teaspoons paprika
- 1 teaspoon garam masala
- 1/2 teaspoon turmeric
- 1/2 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
- 4 to matoes, chopped (about 2 1/2 cups chopped, see note 3)
- 2 teaspoons sugar
- 3/4 cup water, can substitute with broth
- 3 tablespoons heavy cream
- 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon cayenne pepper (see note 4)
To Serve
- cooked basmati rice
- cilantro (optional)
- red pepper flakes (optional)
Instructions
- Slice the block of paneer into 1-inch cubes. Then, slice each cube into 2 or 3 slices. Transfer the paneer to a mixing bowl.
- In a small bowl, stir the yogurt, ginger, garlic, cumin, paprika, and salt. Pour this yogurt marinade over the paneer and mix together. Refrigerate the paneer for at least 30 minutes.
- Once the paneer has been marinated, pan fry the paneer. Heat a nonstick frying pan (or well-seasoned cast-iron skillet) with 1 1/2 tablespoons of oil over medium heat. Arrange the pieces of paneer over the pan in a single layer. You probably need to fry the paneer in batches. Cook for 2 to 3 minutes until golden brown. Flip over all the pieces, and pan fry for another 2 minutes.
- Transfer the fried paneer to a plate and turn off the heat. Quickly wipe down the pan with a paper towel and return the heat to medium.
- Drizzle the remaining 1 1/2 tablespoons of oil to the pan and cook the remaining paneer. Because the pan is very hot already, be careful as you add the paneer to the pan, as it will splatter. Save any leftover yogurt marinade. You will add it to the sauce later. Transfer the cooked paneer to a pan.
- In a separate large sauté pan, add another 2 tablespoons of safflower oil over medium heat. Add the onions and 1/2 teaspoon salt and cook for 5 minutes. Stir frequently to prevent the onions from burning. If the onions brown very quickly, reduce the heat slightly.
- Add the ginger, garlic, coriander, paprika, garam masala, turmeric, black pepper, and remaining teaspoon of salt to the skillet. Cook for 30 seconds and coat the onions with the spices.
- Add the tomatoes, sugar, and water, and reduce the heat to medium-low (see note 5). Cover the pan, and let everything simmer for 10 minutes. Remove the lid and add the heavy cream, leftover yogurt marinade, and cayenne pepper. Stir to combine.
- If you are blending the sauce, turn off the heat now and let the sauce cool for 5 minutes before transferring to a blender to blend. Pour the sauce back into the pan and turn the heat to medium.
- Finally, add the cooked paneer to the sauce and let it heat up for about 1 minute. Turn off the heat. Garnish the paneer tikka masala with cilantro and pepper flakes, if you like. Serve with cooked basmati rice or jasmine rice.
Notes
- I used store-bought paneer for this recipe because it is sturdier. You can also use homemade paneer.
- I don’t recommend using Greek yogurt because it isn’t runny enough.
- If you don’t have fresh tomatoes, you can use 2 1/2 cups crushed or diced tomatoes (about 2/3 of a large can of tomatoes). Note that canned tomatoes tend to be more acidic than fresh tomatoes. As a result, you many need to add 1 or 2 more teaspoons of sugar to balance out the acidity.
- I purposely added the cayenne pepper in the end because this gives the dish spice without it being overly fiery. If you simmer the tomatoes with cayenne pepper at the beginning, the spiciness will be much more intense.
- If you want more sauce, you can add a 1/4 cup more water as you simmer the tomatoes. Note that you’ll add to need a bit more salt so that the sauce doesn’t taste watered down.
Nutrition
Meredith Sherlock says
I saw this recipe on instagram a few days ago and knew I HAD to make it – paneer tikka masala is my favourite Indian dish, after all. So, this evening I made this recipe for my family for dinner and everyone so was impressed! I decided to blend the sauce and the result was so creamy and balanced. The flavours throughout were so delicious and held so much depth. I also added 1/2 a teaspoon of cayenne, which brought some excellent heat to the dish (if you love spicy stuff!). All in all, wonderful flavours and so easy to put together! I definitely will be re-making! Thanks Lisa!
Lisa Lin says
Meredith, thank you so much for trying out the recipe!!
Julia T says
Love this recipe! Even my husband who doesn’t like Indian food said it was ‘acceptable’ – which is big coming from him. I added some frozen peas in the end for extra veggies just before I added the panner. I made a mistake and added ‘hot paprika’ instead of normal paprika… will be using normal paprika next time to control the spiciness level a bit. But that was my mistake, the recipe itself is awesome.
Lisa Lin says
Julia, thank you so much for trying this!! Love the frozen pea addition!
NANCY says
I’ve made Tikka Masala many times before but never with paneer. It was wonderful! I’ll definitely make this again and again. I blended the sauce and I loved the texture and flavor of this dish. I used a scant teaspoon of cayenne and heat was just perfect. Thanks for another wonderful recipe.
Lisa Lin says
Thank you for making this, Nancy! So glad you enjoyed it!!
Polson wanjala says
I want to try it today. I am a chef my customer has requested for Panneer tikka masala. I will use this recipe.
Steve says
Our first attempt at this dish. It had more of a tomato taste than the dish we get At our Indian restaurant. Maybe we need to use more cream? Also the paneer fell apart a bit, which doesn’t happen when we just cook it in ghee.
Lisa Lin says
Hi Steve, yes, you can add more cream if you want to neutralize the tomato. I try not to add too much cream to my dishes. Did you use packaged paneer or fresh paneer for this one?
Stephen Meyers says
Packaged paneer made in small batches by local company
Uma says
Thank you for this easy and healthy recipe. I just made it with the slight modification of broiling the paneer in the oven instead of on the stove, and it came out great. The flavour kick is perfect and it doesn’t feel heavy at all since there is no ghee used. Definitely will be making this again!
Chelsea kram says
This looks soooo good! Adding it to my menu for the month!
Amanda says
This was so fabulous! We have a little Himalayan restaurant near us that makes the best tikka masala I’ve ever had. This was sooo close to theirs it was ridiculous! My guess is that the difference is more heavy cream, but I definitely prefer the lighter version for a regular weeknight meal. Love that it’s vegetarian, too! My picky vegetarian daughter tried it and demanded I save this recipe. I skipped the hot pepper because I’m the only one who likes any kind of heat. I served it with naan. I man near licked the pan when I put away the leftovers. Thank you for the wonderful recipe!
Lisa Lin says
Hi Amanda, thank you so much for trying the recipe! I’m so glad that your daughter enjoyed it!!
Sajeda says
Hi there! I have paneer on the menu tonight and this recipe sounds divine. One quick question – I have frozen, fried paneer from the Indian grocery store. Should I left it defrost, marinate and maybe bake? Any recommendations would be appreciated! Thank you!
Lisa Lin says
Hi, Sajeda! I think that can work if you want to marinate and bake. I’d probably pan fry it myself because I prefer the texture slightly more, but it’s up to you!
Sajeda says
Hi there! I actually ended up pan frying and it was amazing! My husband thought this tasted better then something he’d find at a restaurant. Thank you so much!
Lisa Lin says
Sajeda, thank you SO much for making it! So glad you husband enjoyed it too!
Jade says
Just used this recipe for my very first time making Paneer Tikka Masala! It was super tasty, can’t wait to try out more recipes by you 🙂
Lisa Lin says
Hi Jade, thank you so much for trying the recipe! I’m so glad you enjoyed it!
Christine says
Amazing recipe! So flavorful with layered levels of flavour. It has depth without being too hot or spicy. I like that you suggested to add the cayenne at the end, so that the heat doesn’t develop too much. Love it and highly recommend to all!
Lisa Lin says
Christine, thank you so much for making the recipe!
Marion Clarke says
Hi Lisa! I’ve made this dish quite a few times now and my family loves it. In fact, just last night I was talking my son Caolan through the marinading stage. He’s cooking up an Indian feast for his for university housemates this evening and has been preparing two lots of paneer, as he is using this recipe for one and the other is going to be added to dhal so it is currently marinading in yoghurt with fresh, chilli, garlic and ginger. Wish him luck — this is just one of a number of dishes he’s cooking for his friends! 🙂
marion
Anne says
Can I use yoghurt instead of cream?
Lisa Lin says
Yes, but make sure it is runny yogurt (i.e., not greek yogurt) so that it blends with the sauce. I’d also try to use whole yogurt for this. Mix in the yogurt at the very end.
Keri says
Hi there – I made this awhile back and it was great. I would like to make it again but I’m not in the mood for yogurt this time around. Do you think it’s possible to sub cottage cheese for the yogurt for the paneer marinade? My thought is to blend the cottage cheese to break down the curds to create a smoother mixture that’s similar to that of yogurt. Do you think that would work?
Lauren Ross says
SO yummy! Hands down the best tikka recipe I’ve made at home (and I’ve tried a bunch!) I think the fresh tomatoes made a big difference. I’m already excited to make it again!
Isan gupta says
Thank you for such an amaing recipe. Please follow http://www.temptingrecipe.com
Ashwini says
Hey,
Good one!
Paneer Tikka
Elisa says
Do you think I could substitute coconut cream instead of the cream?
Lisa Lin says
If you don’t mind the heavy coconut flavor, I think it’s okay.
Laura Giffen says
Tried this for tonight’s dinner – delish!! Tasted just like takeout. One small changed – used 3 chopped tomatoes and a can of crushed tomatoes – blended everything before adding paneer back to pan. So good.
Merita says
This was really yummy and good. I did use greek yogurt and thought it worked fine. This was my first try at Indian food and I thought it was restaurant quality.
Lisa Lin says
Thanks, Merita!